Migration Council chief slams criminalsing wage theft

Good news from Domain:

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has put employers on notice that those who exploit workers may soon face criminal penalties, after a company whose directors include celebrity chef George Calombaris was fined for underpaying staff $7.8 million.

“Right now, the Attorney-General is drafting laws to deal with criminalising worker exploitation,” Mr Morrison confirmed during parliamentary question time on Wednesday.

But no. The Migration Council of Australia chairman, Innes Willox, just couldn’t help himself, also at Domain:

Innes Willox said “the vast majority of employers” did not underpay staff and most underpayments were the result of “genuine errors”.

He said criminal cases “would not deliver back-pay” to underpaid workers, whose civil cases would likely be “put on hold until the criminal case is concluded”.

How on earth can this sit alongside the Migration Council’s mission statement:

The Migration Council Australia (MCA) is an independent, non-partisan, not-for-profit body established to enhance the productive benefits of Australia’s migration and humanitarian programs.

MCA brings together corporate Australia and the community sector to provide a national voice to advocate for effective settlement and migration programs.

We believe that the success of the migration program is critical to Australia’s future prosperity. Assisting new migrants and refugees to settle is an investment in the future of the Australian community, our economy and our prospective workforce.

Our aim is to promote greater understanding of migration and settlement and to foster the development of partnerships between corporate Australia, the community sector and Government.

MCA will contribute to the process of public policy making and encourage the development of support services for new arrivals.

Excluding, it seems, preventing the wholesale exploitation of migrants as virtual slaves.

Then again, why not? It’s all an innocent mistake. The LNP Government accidentally ran mass immigration at unprecedented levels into huge supply side slack:

Businesses everywhere made a collective oversight when they mistook migrants for a ready supply of slaves:

  • For years we have seen Dominos, Caltex, 7-Eleven, Woolworths and many other fast food franchises busted for rorting migrant labour.
  • The issue culminated in 2016 when the Senate Education and Employment References Committee released a scathing report entitled A National Disgrace: The Exploitation of Temporary Work Visa Holders, which documented systemic abuses of Australia’s temporary visa system for foreign workers.
  • Mid 2017, ABC’s 7.30 Report ran a disturbing expose on the modern day slavery occurring across Australia.
  • Meanwhile, Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO), Natalie James, told Fairfax that people on visas continue to be exploited at an alarming rate, particularly those with limited English-language skills. It was also revealed that foreign workers are involved in more than three-quarters of legal cases initiated by the FWO against unscrupulous employers.
  • Then The ABC reported that Australia’s horticulture industry is at the centre of yet another migrant slave scandal, according to an Australian Parliamentary Inquiry into the issue.
  • The same Parliamentary Inquiry was told by an undercover Malaysian journalist that foreign workers in Victoria were “brainwashed” and trapped in debt to keep them on farms.
  • UNSW Sydney and UTS survey painted the most damning picture of all, reporting that wages theft is endemic among international students, backpackers and other temporary migrants.
  • A few months ago, Fair Work warned that most of Western Sydney had become a virtual special economic zone in which two-thirds of businesses were underpaying workers, with the worst offenders being high-migrant areas.
  • Dr Bob Birrell from the Australian Population Research Institute latest released a report, based on 2016 Census data, revealed that most recently arrived skilled migrants (i.e. arrived between 2011 and 2016) cannot find professional jobs, with only 24% of skilled migrants from Non-English-Speaking-Countries (who comprise 84% of the total skilled migrant intake) employed as professionals as of 2016, compared with 50% of skilled migrants from Main English-Speaking-Countries and 58% of the same aged Australian-born graduates. These results accord with a survey from the Bankwest Curtin Economics Centre, which found that 53% of skilled migrants in Western Australia said they are working in lower skilled jobs than before they arrived, with underemployment also rife.
  • The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) latest Characteristics of Recent Migrants reportrevealed that migrants have generally worse labour market outcomes than the Australian born population, with recent migrants and temporary residents having an unemployment rate of 7.4% versus 5.4% for the Australian born population, and lower labour force participation (69.8%) than the Australian born population (70.2%).
  • ABC Radio recently highlighted the absurdity of Australia’s ‘skilled’ migration program in which skilled migrants have grown increasingly frustrated at not being able to gain work in Australia despite leaving their homelands to fill so-called ‘skills shortages’. As a result, they are now demanding that taxpayers provide government-sponsored internships to help skilled migrants gain local experience, and a chance to work in their chosen field.
  • In early 2018 the senate launched the”The operation and effectiveness of the Franchising Code of Conduct” owing in part to systematic abuse of migrant labour.
  • Then there is new was research from the University of Sydney documenting the complete corruption of the temporary visas system, and arguing that Australia running a “de-facto low-skilled immigration policy” (also discussed here at the ABC).
  • In late June 2018 the government released new laws to combat modern slavery which, bizarrely, imposed zero punishment for enslaving coolies.
  • Over the following few months we witnessed widespread visa rorting across cafes and restaurants, including among high end establishments like the Rockpool Group.
  • Then Alan Fels, head of the Migrant Workers Taskforce, revealed that international students are systematically exploited particularly by bosses of the same ethnicity.

The visa system collapsed entirely by accident, from Chapter 13 entitled Temporary migrant workers (TMWs), underpayment and predatory business models, written by Iain Campbell:

This chapter argues that the expansion of temporary labour migration is a significant development in Australia and that it has implications for wage stagnation…

Three main facts about their presence in Australia are relevant to the discussion of wage stagnation. First, there are large numbers of TMWs in Australia, currently around 1.2 million persons. Second, those numbers have increased strongly over the past 15 years. Third, when employed, many TMWs are subject to exploitation, including wage payments that fall below — sometimes well below — the minimum levels specified in employment regulation…

One link to slow wages growth, as highlighted by orthodox economics, stems from the simple fact of increased numbers, which add to labour supply and thereby help to moderate wages growth. This chapter argues, however, that the more salient point concerns the way many TMWs are mistreated within the workplace in industry sectors such as food services, horticulture, construction, personal services and cleaning. TMW underpayments, which appear both widespread in these sectors and systemic, offer insights into labour market dynamics that are also relevant to the general problem of slow wages growth…

Official stock data indicate that the visa programmes for international students, temporary skilled workers and working holiday makers have tripled in numbers since the late 1990s… In all, the total number of TMWs in Australia is around 1.2 million persons. If we include New Zealand citizens and permanent residents, who can enter Australia under a special subclass 444 visa, without time limits on their stay and with unrestricted work rights (though without access to most social security payments), then the total is close to 2 million persons… TMWs now make up around 6% of the total Australian workforce…

Decisions by the federal Coalition government under John Howard to introduce easier pathways to permanent residency for temporary visa holders, especially international students and temporary skilled workers, gave a major impetus to TMW visa programmes.

Most international students and temporary skilled workers, together with many working holiday makers, see themselves as involved in a project of ‘staggered’ or ‘multi-step’ migration, whereby they hope to leap from their present status into a more long-term visa status, ideally permanent residency. One result, as temporary migration expands while the permanent stream remains effectively capped, is a lengthening queue of onshore applicants for permanent residency…

Though standard accounts describe Australian immigration as oriented to skilled labour, this characterisation stands at odds with the abundant evidence on expanding temporary migration and the character of TMW jobs. It is true that many TMWs, like their counterparts in the permanent stream, are highly qualified and in this sense skilled. However, the fact that their work is primarily in lower-skilled jobs suggests that it is more accurate, as several scholars point out, to speak of a shift in Australia towards a de facto low-skilled migration programme

A focus on raw numbers of TMWs may miss the main link to slow wages growth. It is the third point concerning underpayments and predatory business models that seems richest in implications. This point suggests, first and most obviously, added drag on wages growth in sectors where such underpayments and predatory business models have become embedded. If they become more widely practised, underpayments pull down average hourly wages. If a substantial number of firms in a specific labour market intensify strategies of labour cost minimisation by pushing wage rates below the legal floor, it can unleash a dynamic of competition around wage rates that foreshadows wage decline rather than wage growth for employees…

Increases in labour supply allow employers in sectors already oriented to flexible and low-wage employment, such as horticulture and food services, to sustain and extend strategies of labour cost minimisation… The arguments and evidence cited above suggest a spread of predatory business models within low-wage industries.37 They suggest an unfolding process of degradation in these labour markets…

And below are extracts from Chapter 14, entitled Is there a wages crisis facing skilled temporary migrants?, by Joanna Howe:

Scarcely a day goes by without another headline of wage theft involving temporary migrant workers…

In this chapter we explore a largely untold story in relation to temporary migrant workers… it exposes a very real wages crisis facing workers on the Temporary Skill Shortage (TSS) visa (formerly the 457 visa) in Australia. This crisis has been precipitated by the federal government’s decision to freeze the salary floor for temporary skilled migrant workers since 2013… the government has chosen to put downward pressure on real wages for temporary skilled migrants, thereby surreptitiously allowing the TSS visa to be used in lower-paid jobs…

In Australia, these workers are employed via the TSS visa and they must be paid no less than a salary floor. This salary floor is called the Temporary Skilled Migration Income Threshold (TSMIT). TSMIT was introduced in 2009 in response to widespread concerns during the Howard Government years of migrant worker exploitation. This protection was considered important because an independent review found that many 457 visa workers were not receiving wages equivalent to those received by Australian workers…

In effect, TSMIT is intended to act as a proxy for the skill level of a particular occupation. It prevents unscrupulous employers misclassifying an occupation at a higher skill level in order to employ a TSS visa holder at a lower level…

TSMIT’s protective ability is only as strong as the level at which it is set. In its original iteration back in 2009, it was set at A$45 220. This level was determined by reference to average weekly earnings for Australians, with the intention that TSMIT would be pegged to this because the Australian government considered it ‘important that TSMIT keep pace with wage growth across the Australian labour market’. This indexation occurred like clockwork for five years. But since 1 July 2013, TSMIT has been frozen at a level of A$53 900. ..

There is now a gap of more than A$26 000 between the salary floor for temporary skilled migrant workers and annual average salaries for Australian workers. This means that the TSS visa can increasingly be used to employ temporary migrant workers in occupations that attract a far lower salary than that earned by the average Australian worker. This begs the question — is the erosion of TSMIT allowing the TSS visa to morph into a general labour supply visa rather than a visa restricted to filling labour market gaps in skilled, high-wage occupations?..

But why would employers go to all the effort of hiring a temporary migrant worker on a TSS visa over an Australian worker?

Renowned Australian demographer Graeme Hugo observed that employers ‘will always have a “demand” for foreign workers if it results in a lowering of their costs’.  The simplistic notion that employers will only go to the trouble and expense of making a TSS visa application when they want to meet a skill shortage skims over a range of motives an employer may have for using the TSS visa. These could be a reluctance to invest in training for existing or prospective staff, or a desire to move towards a deunionised workforce. Additionally, for some employers, there could be a belief that, despite the requirement that TSS visa workers be employed on equivalent terms to locals, it is easier to avoid paying market salary rates and conditions for temporary migrant workers who have been recognised as being in a vulnerable labour market position. A recent example of this is the massive underpayments of chefs and cooks employed by Australia’s largest high-end restaurant business, Rockpool Dining Group, which found that visa holders were being paid at levels just above TSMIT but well below the award when taking into account the amount of overtime being done…

Put simply, temporary demand for migrant workers often creates a permanent need for them in the labour market. Research shows that in industries where employers have turned to temporary migrants en masse, it erodes wages and conditions in these industries over time, making them less attractive to locals…

A national survey of temporary migrant workers found that 24% of 457 visa holders who responded to the survey were paid less than A$18 an hour.  Not only are these workers not being paid in according with TSMIT, but they are also receiving less than the minimum wage. A number of cases also expose creative attempts by employers to subvert TSMIT. Given the challenges many temporary migrants face in accessing legal remedies, these cases are likely only scratching the surface in terms of employer non-compliance with TSMIT…

Combined, then, with the problems with enforcement and compliance, it is not hard to conclude that the failure to index TSMIT is contributing to a wages crisis for skilled temporary migrant workers… So the failure to index the salary floor for skilled migrant workers is likely to affect wages growth for these workers, as well as to have broader implications for all workers in the Australian labour market.

The entire mass immigration model is just a little error:

  • students, visa holders, tourists all work for nothing to gain longer terms visas;
  • their numbers are endless and so is the labour supply shock;
  • and that endless flow has now generated a supply side adjustment to businesses that thrive on cheap foreign labour – basically service economy dross – that holds up empty calorie growth, boosts asset prices and the currency, holds own productivity via capital shallowing, and hollows out tradables in an era of global lowflation.

Thus everybody can get some work, nobody can get enough of it, participation skyrockets but productivity craters. Wages can’t rise and the economy spirals, literally, into a dumbening singularity.

Nothing to see here.

David Llewellyn-Smith
Latest posts by David Llewellyn-Smith (see all)


  1. If wage underpayment is a result of genuine errors, which should follow normal statistical distribution, then one would expect an equal amount of overpayment. Is this the case???

  2. Oh yes, Seven Eleven and others are not repeat offenders but “accidents”

    Yeah, nah Innes. How a paper can publish such dross and expects to be taken seriously amazes me.

  3. Touching how concerned he is about outcomes for workers whose wages have been stolen.

    Just another Ozzigarch crying crocodile tears for his victims.

  4. You should know how much you’re due to get paid. If you’re being underpaid just go and work somewhere else and file a claim for the underpayment. Don’t drag it out and then make yourself out to be some sort of victim.

    • I actually agree with you – first responsibility lies with the employee: know what you are supposed to be paid; if you don’t get it, request it; if you get pushed back by the employee, then go higher; etc.

      • +1 I worked for an Irish company that decided to never define or pay a bonus that was in my contract. So after raising it for a year and getting nowhere I gave them 2 weeks notice. I got a good shouting down in front of the whole company (glass office) about how I needed to provide a full 4 weeks notice. I sat there calmly and said I’m sorry but I don’t feel I’m being paid fairly and therefore I don’t think the contract is binding. The lady (boss’ sister) was yelling at me, whilst I sat there calmly and said nope, see ya.

        I got a lot of kudos from the others watching on after.. The best part was remaining calm when being shouted at. The more she shouted and angrier she got the calmer I was. I could tell that just irritated her more.

        I heard they dropped 30% of the staff after that (GFC hit) and this was mid 2008. Never looked back.

      • drsmithyMEMBER

        I actually agree with you – first responsibility lies with the employee: know what you are supposed to be paid; if you don’t get it, request it; if you get pushed back by the employee, then go higher; etc.

        This is only possible for employes who have a base level of bargaining power. So… unionised, with sufficient financial resources to survive sudden unemployment, or able to easily find another job.

  5. I was looking for the phrase “prolapsed anus” in there, but appear to have missed it.

  6. Just imagine how much of this is happening in construction and agriculture- that is never going to be discovered

    • Yes, agreed…

      “But I can’t find Australian employees (who will work for far less than they ought to be paid)!”

      So, get it foreign slaves who don’t know their rights, happy to live in share-hovels, happy to get enough AUD to send home, and don’t have a voice, and are afraid to exercise their rights for fear of being sent home anyway…

      Add abbatoirs to that list, too, I bet…

  7. Mining BoganMEMBER

    Listening to a conversation about common criminal George and Masterthief and all that on the wireless this morning. Not one of the people involved would say wage theft. They’d say financial difficulties or wage payment set-up or something equally shifty. Never wage theft.

    The Melbourne set is desperately trying to protect George and all other common thievery. The Innes idiot is just another part of the protection racket.

    • Yes. How on earth do you overlook $7.8 million??

      I suspect they really just got caught with their hands in the cookie jar.

      Not to mention the LNP and their long-term objective to pump property prices whilst driving down wages – they have created an Australian underclass (how good is egalitarianism?); made worse by under-paying foreigners wrt average Aussie wages.

    • +1 I can’t stand people who support this fwit of a chef. haha. Master chef what a load of bollocks.

  8. JunkyardMEMBER

    Yeah nah, they’ll draft up a few laws then make example of a few dodgy small-time Vietnamese restaurant operators on Victoria street which no one cares about.

    Problem solved, Scomo saves the day, let’s move on to the next news cycle of how good are Straya property prices rebounding!

  9. SchillersMEMBER

    Does anyone know if the hundreds of thousands of international students currently studying in Australia are included in the 2 million total for Temporary Migrant Workers (TMW)? Or are they in addition to it?

  10. Jumping jack flash

    Interesting. Im waiting for the banks to have a say but they would never say it publicly.

    More likely, after a quick phone call from either the RBA or another of the “rulers of our economy” the whole thing will be quietly forgotten.

    The exploited immigrants play a vital role in debt expansion, which is synonymous with economic expansion in the new economy.

    This is due to debt saturation, gouged costs of living, stagnant wages, hyper-competitive and globalised markets and the requirement for ever larger mountains of debt to be successful. All of these effects are interlinked and as each one increases it causes more of the others.