Canada shows Australia how to solve housing crisis

Advertisement

Canada experienced an unprecedented immigration boom after the pandemic, which caused a record housing shortage.

Canadian population versus supply

As a result, Canada’s rental vacancy rate fell to a record low and rental inflation soared, delivering the worst rental crisis in living memory.

Canadian rental market
Advertisement

The following chart from the National Bank of Canada estimates that the nation’s shortage of rental housing exceeds 450,000 units.

Canada's rental housing deficit

The situation is changing, however, following the Canadian government’s immigration freeze.

Advertisement

Following an intense voter backlash, Canada’s Liberal Government admitted that immigration had been too high and implemented an immigration/population “freeze” aimed at stabilising the population at its current level for three years.

Canada immigration freeze

The immigration freeze has proven effective, with Canada’s quarterly population growth plunging to only 20,100 in Q2 2025. Only two other quarters in history have shown weaker population growth: during the pandemic in 2020, when border restrictions prevented any growth, and in 2015.

Advertisement
Canadian population growth

Annual population growth remained solid at 1.24% (+510,400 people) in Q2 2025. However, it is less than half the pace of the peak observed in 2023.

Meanwhile, Canadian housing starts remained roughly stable (-700) in May at 279,500 (seasonally adjusted and annualised).

Advertisement
Canadian housing starts

As a result, Canada’s housing shortage and rental crisis are easing.

Indeed, slower population growth has driven eight consecutive monthly declines in Canadian asking rents, which are tracking 3.3% below a year earlier.

Advertisement
Canadian asking rents

“The easing in rents this year across most parts of the country is a positive for housing affordability in Canada following a period of extremely strong rent inflation lasting from 2022 to 2024”, Urbanation president Shaun Hildebrand said.

There are clear lessons here for Australia, where policymakers and the media continue to paint the housing crisis as a “supply issue”.

Advertisement

The latest State of the Housing Report from the National Housing Supply and Affordability Council (NHSAC) forecasts that Australia’s cumulative housing shortage will worsen by 79,000 dwellings over five years.

Housing supply versus demand

NHSAC’s population forecasts are based on the Centre for Population’s projections, which assume permanently high levels of immigration.

Advertisement
Historical NOM

However, NHSAC’s sensitivity analysis showed that if Australia’s population grew by just 15% less than forecast over the next five years, then the projected 79,000 housing shortage would turn into a 40,000 surplus.

NHSAC sensitivity analysis
Advertisement

NHSAC’s sensitivity analysis and Canada’s experience are further evidence that cutting immigration is the only realistic solution to the housing shortage and rental crisis.

About the author
Leith van Onselen is Chief Economist at the MB Fund and MB Super. He is also a co-founder of MacroBusiness. Leith has previously worked at the Australian Treasury, Victorian Treasury and Goldman Sachs.