Morrison whinges as Aussie iron ore returns in Chinese warships

Pig Iron Scott’s storm troopers are upset that China is spying on Australia on the high seas, via the UK Express (there are now two spy ships):

The Australian military is keeping tabs on the PLA naval surveillance ship, Tianwangxing, as it travels towards Queensland waters off the country’s north-east coast. The vessel is widely believed to be planning to observe military drills involving military personnel from Australia and the United States, which got under way this week.

Australian Senator Eric Abetz, chairman of the Senate’s Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Committee, contrasted Beijing’s behaviour with its attitude to ships passing within waters off in south-east Asia.

He told “Australia is carefully monitoring the situation and the timing of the intelligence ship visiting our waters.

“One may well suspect it is a deliberate act ahead of the Talisman Sabre war games.”

While the ship was in Australia’s Exclusive Economic Zone, it was allowed to travel through in accordance with international maritime law, Mr Abetz acknowledged.

However, he added: “It is hypocritical for China to practice freedom of navigation so close to our shores while at the same time voicing loud protestations against other nations that conduct the same freedom of navigation exercises through the South China Sea.

“If Australia or another country were to transit through China’s Exclusive Economic Zone, there would be the predictable belligerent claims from the CCP dictatorship about ‘interference in China’s internal affairs’.”

If we’re going to measure the national interest based upon hypocrisies then how does Australia whinging about its iron ore coming back repurposed as warships stack up? Pretty well, I would have thought.

Which again raises the question, why do we do it? Why do we keep pumping the lifeblood of the growing Chinese tyranny? With perhaps only the exception of oil, iron ore is the key building block of Xi’s dictatorial power, both at home and abroad.

Iron ore is the lynchpin for about half of China’s economy, via industry and construction. Any shortage will SMASH IT.

Given economic advancement is the CCP’s only claim to legitimacy, Australian iron ore is directly supporting its domestic political strength, as well as power projection capability of ships, planes and rifles.

Australia supplies 60% of China’s iron ore needs. There is no way to replace it for five years at least. Probably ten. In that decade, the Chinese economy would be rocked to its core.

Even better, it might goad the CCP into doing something really stupid, like invading Taiwan prematurely, which would rally the free world behind further trade blockades, containing the CCP threat for good.

By comparison, iron ore is nowhere near as important to Australia. Sure, it makes up a large slice of export revenues. But if we refused to sell it to China, the price would go up 1000% and the Australian dollar crater. We’d come out about even. In fact, much better off, as we achieved instant trade diversification.

Such measures may sound extreme but it’s not hard to rationalise them with some realist analysis. If:

  • China is a tyranny, and
  • the CCP is intent on dominating Asia (if not the world)
  • then why wait until it is powerful enough to do so before fighting it?

The reasoning doesn’t even need to be so drastic. Take this line of thought. If:

  • CCP legitamcy is based upon economic advancement, and
  • its economy is headed into the middle-income trap
  • then it will turn to nationalism as the only other form of mass political movement to keep itself in power and it will invade Taiwan, followed by endless border and maritime wars with Korea, Japan, SE Asia Russia, India and the Stans.

At the point of the Taiwan invasion, Australian iron ore will cease to go to China anyway.

So why wait until the CCP is much more powerful and harder to resist? Cut the iron ore now. Cut the CCP off at the knees.

And deliver our kids a dual bounty of sustained commodity endowment plus bulwarked freedom.

Houses and Holes
Latest posts by Houses and Holes (see all)


  1. Maybe just tarriffs of 100% etc like they slap on our wine. And when will we slap tarriffs on their important products like mobile phones, cars, TV’s etc I’m losing face!

  2. SnappedUpSavvyMEMBER

    i have it on good authority the first ship has actually broken down and the second is coming to help

    • blacktwin997MEMBER

      Story checks out, that first ship was sent out to scout the location of a prior stealth ship which arrived early and then sank in the area.

      • That prior spy ship was out desperately looking for their pirate freighter that had lots of dead rare animals on it & it accidentally ripped itself asunder by running into a floating White Rhino horn – this hasn’t helped alleviate any erectile dysfunction neurosis, but has exposed the weakness of their thin skinned hulls.

  3. We’re just annoying China at the moment, imagine their response to threatening their economy?

  4. Hex TexasMEMBER

    Agreed, China have now declared their intentions, and it is clear they have been actively involved in ever increasing asymmetric covert grey warfare for at least the last 15 years, so we need to stop helping them prepare to destroy us. They started this, and appeasement never works !

  5. gballardMEMBER

    Straya is not dissimilar to a sex worker with China the main customer and moreover CCP controlled China pays well !!!

  6. surfbeach2536

    DLS: “Even better, it might goad the CCP into doing something really stupid, like invading Taiwan prematurely, which would rally the free world behind further trade blockades, containing the CCP threat for good.” is sounding a lot like past CIA tactics and a lot of their strategies didn’t go as planned. Better to keep Taiwan free than offer it up as an opening gambit as its loss may be difficult to bear.

    • I agree forcing their hand to invade Taiwan is not a good outcome for the people of Taiwan.