Which big resources firms have further to fall?

Advertisement

More falls today for big iron and gas but the hope is still plain as spreads between local and international prices widens. BHP is down sharply -3.2% but above recent lows, RIO is down -3.1% also above recent lows, but FMG has cracked today finally down -5.2% and in free fall once more despite Dalian opening flat:

tvc_cfab77c4bf17c0587ce20460e03fba19

FMG is looking rather like it is reforming its bearish descending triangle pattern and if it falls through $1.60 or so the chart suggests it’s way to the GFC low at $1.11 and thence oblivion:

tvc_5939e9a148dfec441af4b735bb5b13a4
Advertisement

For the two big miners, it is clear that local prices are outperforming their ADRs and foreign listings. For BHP this is after years of under-performance owing to the high dollar:

tvc_98a5e903615c74e1a2b2b58f7e372762

But not so much for RIO which is kind of odd and suggests that perhaps the army of local investors buying for yield are supporting the stock and are in for a very nasty shock:

Advertisement
tvc_f82f8f488140c876ca939521fb6f3832

Both miners are on the way to 2003 prices in my view.

Big gas is also trying to hang on with falls minimal today despite Brent carnage. WPL and OSH are down just -0.5%, STO and ORG are both up 0.4% and LNG is fast disappearing at -4%:

Advertisement
tvc_8df4f23f26eabd7468c9aa0f75198f3b

I see both STO and ORG as struggling to survive but right now it looks to me like WPL is the new RIO of gas, given it is massively out-performing the underlying commodity, with big further catch-up falls possible:

tvc_62ff342270e6629572fab19fd8ecf4f3
Advertisement

The answer to the article question, then, is all of the above have further to fall.

About the author
David Llewellyn-Smith is Chief Strategist at the MB Fund and MB Super. David is the founding publisher and editor of MacroBusiness and was the founding publisher and global economy editor of The Diplomat, the Asia Pacific’s leading geo-politics and economics portal. He is also a former gold trader and economic commentator at The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, the ABC and Business Spectator. He is the co-author of The Great Crash of 2008 with Ross Garnaut and was the editor of the second Garnaut Climate Change Review.