Is it time for a payroll tax on bank jobs outsourced overseas?
National Australia Bank (NAB) recently announced plans to cut 2,500 jobs by mid-2027, including 1,500 by the end of this year. However, NAB has now revealed it plans to abolish 3,200 jobs before Christmas, although it will invite some displaced staff to apply for new jobs through a process known as ‘spill-and-fill’.
A senior NAB manager has likened the process to the popular film franchise The Hunger Games. Internal figures show NAB’s technology and AI teams will be hit hardest by the job cuts, with around 1,200 roles to be abolished.
While NAB is busy retrenching local staff, it is significantly expanding its technology workforce in Vietnam and India.
NAB has more than 7,000 employees in India and Vietnam, most hired over the past five years. The bank plans to add at least 180 more offshore positions in the near term.
NAB runs a continuous technology internship program called StarCamp at its Vietnam innovation centre, with new intakes occurring every 12 weeks. Around 700 Vietnamese graduates have completed the program.
Interns reportedly receive about A$600 per month during training, and more than 90% move into permanent NAB employment after completing the course.
Some intakes have reportedly contained as many as 70 graduates.
While NAB runs a similar StarCamp program in Melbourne, last year’s Melbourne intake reportedly involved just 40 interns, and the next intake is expected to involve only 10-20 graduates.
The article suggests graduate hiring and technology development are increasingly shifting offshore.
Labour-cost advantages are obviously driving the offshoring of roles. The article estimates that a junior software engineer in Vietnam costs NAB about A$20,000 per year, compared with A$80,000 or more for an equivalent Australian employee.
A payroll tax for offshored jobs?
Given that the main driver of offshoring is usually the wage differential between Australia and offshore locations such as India and Vietnam, consideration should be given to implementing a federal payroll tax on foreign-employed staff.
A payroll tax on overseas employees would narrow the cost gap with local staff, reducing incentives to offshore. It would level the playing field between firms employing Australians and those employing offshore workers.
A payroll tax on overseas employees would also raise much-needed budget revenue, which could fund domestic training or apprenticeships, or simply pay down debt.
Australia’s banks receive billions of dollars in funding benefits from the implicit federal government guarantee on their debt.
Investors believe that if a major Australian bank got into severe trouble, the federal government would likely intervene rather than allow a disorderly collapse.
As a result, rating agencies give the major banks higher credit ratings, bond investors accept lower interest rates, and funding costs are lower than they otherwise would be.
If the major banks want to offshore roles, they should pay a federal payroll tax accordingly.
