More bad news for Sydney and Melbourne house prices

Advertisement

Cotality’s dwelling values results for May confirmed that Sydney and Melbourne are experiencing price corrections, with values declining by more than 2% over the quarter:

Cotality daily index

Source: Cotality

The latest auction results were abysmal for both markets, with Sydney’s average monthly clearance rate plunging to 49% in May to its lowest level since April 2020:

Sydney auction clearance rate vs prices
Advertisement

Melbourne’s auction clearance rate in May fell to 54%, its worst result since July 2022:

Sydney's auction clearance rates vs prices

Meanwhile, as illustrated below by Justin Fabo from Antipodean Macro, for sale listings are piling up in both markets at the same time as buyer demand has evaporated:

Advertisement
Sydney and Melbourne listings

CBA has downgraded its house price forecasts following the federal budget, with Sydney and Melbourne now forecast to experience heavy price corrections this year:

CBA dwelling price forecasts
Advertisement

CBA now forecasts that Sydney and Melbourne dwelling values will decline by 6% and 7%, respectively, in 2026 but will rebound by 3% in 2027:

CBA dwelling price forecasts

Two forecast rate cuts by the RBA next year will drive this rebound:

Advertisement
CBA RBA pricing

CBA estimates that the changes to negative gearing and CGT announced in the federal budget on cash flow for property investors will be the equivalent to 135-165 bp of monetary tightening for Sydney, with lesser impacts for the other markets:

Impact of CGT and NG
Advertisement

My view is that the RBA’s dwelling price forecasts are optimistic, and I see the market experiencing its largest price correction in 40 years, beating the 8.2% decline recorded between 2017 and 2019:

Dwelling price corrections

Source: Cotality

The gap between prices and capacity to pay has never been greater.

Advertisement
Home values versus borrowing capacity

With the housing market facing a multitude of headwinds, including unaffordability, high interest rates, reduced borrowing capacity, consumer gloom, weakening economic activity, and rising unemployment, the ingredients are in place for a significant price correction.

About the author
Leith van Onselen is Chief Economist at the MB Fund and MB Super. He is also a co-founder of MacroBusiness. Leith has previously worked at the Australian Treasury, Victorian Treasury and Goldman Sachs.
Advertisement