This economy is not growing at 5% in anybody’s mind except for the CCP’s and its menagerie of grovellers.
Property is stuffed.

Prices are still falling.

Cars are doing better on the cash-for-clunkers. This was true of consumption more broadly, but much of that is over now after the vouchers were pulled.
Advertisement

But exports are stuffed.

Oil and coal demand are stuffed. This is a little decarbonisation affected, but still…
Advertisement


There is a moderate amount of infrastructure demand, but the services and industry PMIs have flatlined.
Advertisement

This is an economy on life support.