Victorian government taxes economy into oblivion

Advertisement

Victoria’s budget finances are in disarray, with the state carrying the nation’s highest debt and lowest credit rating.

According to the latest state budget, Victoria’s net debt will rise to $194 billion by 2028-29, from $155.5 billion currently.

Victorian net debt

Victorian net debt per capita is the highest in the nation. In 2023-24, Victoria’s per capita net debt was $22,905, well ahead of the other states.

Advertisement
State debt

The Victorian budget projected that net debt per capita would reach $25,500 by 2028-29.

Victorian net debt per capita
Advertisement

Victoria currently spends $6.8 billion on annual interest charges. By 2028-29, Victoria’s interest bill is expected to be $10.6 billion.

Victorian interest expense

Per capita, Victoria’s annual interest expense is expected to climb from $959 in 2024-25 to $1,391 in 2028-29.

Advertisement
Interest expense per capita

With the state’s debt spiraling out of control and ratings agencies threatening further downgrades, the Victorian government has slugged residents and businesses with taxes.

As illustrated in the ABS table below, Victorian state and local government taxes were $6,348 per capita in 2023-24, $654 (11.5%) higher than the state and territory average.

Advertisement
Per capita taxes and debt

Source: ABS

The ABS showed that Victoria experienced a 40.5% rise in state and local government taxes since 2020-21, the largest rise in the nation.

Research from the Institute of Public Affairs (IPA) also estimates that Victorian state taxes now comprise 6.08% of gross state product, making Victoria the highest taxing state in Australia.

Advertisement
Victorian debt

Source: IPA (via Herald-Sun)

Victoria’s high state taxes are having a detrimental impact on economic activity, with many businesses moving their head offices and operations to other jurisdictions.

Analysis by Victoria’s Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO) has concluded that the state will miss out on $37.6 million over the next four years as a result of cruise line Carnival’s decision to stop operating out of Melbourne.

Advertisement

The decision appears to be the result of the Victorian government’s decision to increase berthing fees by 15% in November 2023, with the government claiming the increase was needed to help pay for maintenance of Station Pier, which is nearly 100 years old.

Cruise berting fees

The foregone $37.6 million is made up of $9.8 million in lost tax to the Victorian government and $27.8 million lost to Melbourne’s tourism sector.

Advertisement

“The passenger cruise industry is a significant contributor to the tourism industry in Victoria. A total of 128 vessel berths were recorded during the 2023-24 cruise season, with the average vessel hosting more than 1500 passengers”, the PBO analysis says.

The Age noted that “the forward schedule for cruise ship berthings at Station Pier, published on the Ports Victoria website, reveals there will be a 66% fall in expected visits to the city in the next four years, dropping from 103 visits in 2024-25 to 75 in 2025-26, 71 in 2026-27 and just 36 in 2027-28”.

Cruise ship impacts
Advertisement

Carnival Corporation’s country manager, Peter Little, claimed that Melbourne has become one of the world’s most expensive cities for a cruise line to visit.

“Home-ported ships are incredibly valuable to the Victorian economy because many of our guests will stay in Melbourne before or after their cruise, to explore city attractions or dine in restaurants”, he said. “We also sourced an enormous volume of food and beverages locally, when our ships were based in Melbourne.”

The Victorian government is stifling business and reducing our income while spending exorbitantly on bureaucrats, wasteful projects, and increasing taxes.

Advertisement
About the author
Leith van Onselen is Chief Economist at the MB Fund and MB Super. He is also a co-founder of MacroBusiness. Leith has previously worked at the Australian Treasury, Victorian Treasury and Goldman Sachs.