Economists: Rebooting immigration will drive up unemployment

For many months, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has argued that Australia’s unemployment rate will need to fall toward 4% or lower to tighten the labour market significantly enough to generate wage growth.

Thanks to the heavy fall in migrant workers due to COVID:

Temporary visa holders

Big fall in temporary visa holders.

Australia’s unemployment rate fell to 4.6% in July – the lowest reading since December 2008:

Unemployment rate

Lowest unemployment rate since December 2008.

Now economists are warning that rebooting immigration post pandemic, as forecast by the Intergenerational Report:

Net overseas migration

Back to ‘Big Australia’ immigration.

Would necessarily drive unemployment back up, in turn scuttling the RBA’s unemployment and wage growth targets:

An exodus of more than 300,000 foreign workers since the virus hit early last year helped drive the unemployment rate below 5 per cent before the recent lockdowns in NSW and Victoria.

But when the international border reopens and foreign workers return, it will become harder to reduce the official jobless rate, according to economists.

[The monthly ABS labour force survey] showed resident employment was 100,000 above pre-pandemic levels at more than 13 million people. But these stronger figures only include the civilian Australian resident population…

“It [the international border closure] makes it easier for the labour market to tighten and the unemployment rate to fall as more jobs open up for domestic workers,” [CBA head of Australian economics Gareth Aird said]….

CBA’s Mr Aird said when the international border reopened to non-resident workers… it’s possible the job vacancies start to go down but you won’t see the consummate lift in employment because it will be foreign workers taking the jobs”…

National Australia economist Taylor Nugent said…”labour supply dislocation from closed international borders is likely to continue to contribute to labour shortages in certain industries”…

None of this should be remotely controversial or come as a surprise. Achieving the RBA’s goals explicitly requires Australia’s immigration intake not to return to pre-COVID levels.

Importing 180,000-plus migrant workers into Australia every year, as was was the case pre-pandemic, would necessarily drive up labour supply and unemployment, lower worker bargaining power, and place downward pressure on Australian wages – as was the empirical evidence over the prior decade.

Unconventional Economist
Latest posts by Unconventional Economist (see all)


  1. As recently as this week, independent-as-always Treasury mandarin Jenny Wilkinson has set Phil Lowe to rights, in front of the Big Australia devotees at ANU Crawford School. “There’s actually little or no proof,” her performance-bonus and promotional-prospects boldly declared, of “a destructive impression of migration on wages.”

    • I wonder who pays her wages? The good old Australian 7taxpayer? Perhaps she has a special skill like being a service station attendant. She appears to be overpaid where she is.

      “Over the course of her career, Jenny has held positions across a number of different departments and agencies. These have included running the Parliamentary Budget Office, from July 2017 to January 2020, and prior to that, holding senior positions in the Commonwealth Treasury, the Department of Industry, the Department of Climate Change, the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet and the Reserve Bank of Australia. Working in these roles, she has been responsible for providing advice on a wide range of economic policy issues.
      Jenny has served on a number of advisory boards including the ANU Tax Transfer Institute Advisory Board, the ANU College of Business and Economics Advisory Board, the Grattan Institute Public Policy Committee and the Melbourne Institute Advisory Board.

      Jenny holds a Masters Degree in Public Affairs from Princeton University and a Bachelors Degree in Economics (with Honours) from the Australian National University.”

      Perhaps she would do less damage if she picked fruit.

      What a fool

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in now