Locusts: Lower immigration “disastrous” for property market

Oh, how times have changed. Before the COVID-19 pandemic hit, the property lobby and government continuously claimed that Australia’s housing affordability woes were due to a chronic lack of supply and not impacted by Australia’s turbocharged immigration intake.

Now, the story coming from the property lobby is the polar opposite, with the industry warning of impending doom unless immigration levels are quickly rebooted:

Dwindling migration is set to drag Australian population growth to a 103-year low with potentially disastrous results for the housing market.

Property research group CoreLogic warned the slowdown would have an impact on construction, rents and off-the-plan apartment sales.

Group head of research Tim Lawless said the construction sector was particularly exposed…

Lower migration could have the added effect of causing a protracted drop in rents within inner city areas considering overseas arrivals normally make up a large share of the tenants.

Falls in rents could also force down prices as there would be fewer investors willing to purchase units they may struggle to tenant.

This would increase “settlement risk” for buyers of units sold off-the-plan – a situation where the value of a property drops below the purchase price in the time it takes to get built…

Nearly 85 per cent of overseas migration last year flowed into capital cities and three quarters of the that movement went to Sydney and Melbourne…

“The impact of the sharp fall in overseas arrivals can already be seen in surging inner city rental advertisements, with rental listings more than doubling across some key inner city unit precincts…

“The rise in available rental stock in these precincts is already weighing on rental income.

“Every capital city is showing a larger fall in unit rents relative to house rents through the COVID period to-date, with a more significant difference in Melbourne and Sydney”…

With rents reducing the ability of landlords to service their mortgages, there could be more distressed listings within inner Sydney and Melbourne…

“Many of the aforementioned inner city precincts are toward the end of a surge in new apartment supply …

“Many of these yet-to-be completed projects will settle while rental vacancies remain high and rents are falling, which may put downward pressure on property values.”

ABS building activity data showed there were more than 50,000 units under construction across NSW at the end of March, and just over 45,000 across Victoria.

Mr Lawless said lower population growth would affect the market for some time.

Keep this handy for the next time a spokesperson for property groups and denialists in the media (including the ABC) make baseless claims that long-term high immigration is not a political strategy to put upward pressure on property prices and rents.

Leith van Onselen
Latest posts by Leith van Onselen (see all)


  1. Display NameMEMBER

    This is one of the core Property Ponzi Conundrums akin to Schrodinger’s cat in physics.

    Whilst property prices increase, the migration rate has nothing to do with house prices. But apparently not paradoxically, if house prices decrease, migration must be one of the main reasons.

      • Cue Ariel Pink:

        What a fine day
        After we spa
        Netflix and chill where we [?]
        She sent for my Uber ’cause she wanted some d!ck

        Hurricane junkhead melody lounge
        Protein shake ooooo?
        Its so easy its almost a crime

        ‘Cause I’m a dreamdate narcissist
        ‘Cause I’m a dreamdate narcissist
        ‘Cause I’m a dreamdate that’s when we started to kiss

  2. Goldstandard1MEMBER

    This is great though. It’s great in the sense that it has exposed in black and white what was behind the curtain – as the immigration tap slowly gets turned on and people here have no jobs, at least there is PROOF of how much immigration is needed to keep house prices high. It at least strengthens the argument not to go back to the way it was.

    • Fabian AlderseyMEMBER

      Does it though? If immigration ramps up and they go back to claiming it has no effect, who in the media will call them out on it?
      It’s just like super confident economists making predictions and not noting all their previous failed predictions.

  3. It’s like the Sydney/Melbourne spruikers.

    When commodity prices are high they complain about the “Two Speed Economy” and insist they must be subsidised by the internationally competititive exporting states out of fairness.

    When commodity prices are low they claim they are the “Engines of Growth” . . . . and must be subsidised because they’re driving the Australian economy.

    Never expect self-interest to respect logic or consistency.

  4. Properties in western Sydney 40km from the city center are still at record highs and approx 800k plus in price. Even if they fell 50%, they are still expensive, unaffordable for many, and would still be lining pockets of longer term investors, developers etc.
    The average family in Sydney really hasn’t got much hope.

  5. Wonder if it’s a bit of wordsmith trickery by the locusts. They claim that ‘immigrants don’t increase house prices’, rather than ‘immigration doesn’t increase house prices’.

    It’s kind of true, individuals don’t place broad-based demand on the system. And of course, it comes across as a ‘don’t be ray-shist’ message which always makes them look good, and serves as a warning to any who raise the issue of immigration driving up house prices (‘don’t make me come over there and call you a racialist!’).

  6. Dwindling migration is set to drag Australian population growth to a 103-year low with potentially disastrous marvellous and beneficial results for the housing market, the environment, infrastructure, transport times and every other single aspect of life in this country that anybody could think of.

    That is the actual truth of the matter.

  7. Terrible, tragic news. I only saw the other day my local real estate agent driving around in a 2019 BMW. 2019!!!!. Coronavirus be damned, open the gates, lower the rates.

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in now