Victoria’s ponzi economy exposed

Earlier this week, Victoria was ranked the number one economy by CommSec’s State of the States report, which drew a triumphant response from Victorian Treasurer Tim “Ponzi” Pallas:

“This latest data confirms what we already knew – Victoria is the nation’s economic pacesetter.” “Sound economic management and projects like the Metro Tunnel, level crossing removals and the North East Link are delivering rewards across key performance indicators, like jobs growth, retail trade or construction activity.” “We’ll keep on punching above our weight to create jobs and lay the foundations for future growth and prosperity.”

As we noted at the time, the areas driving Victoria’s so-called “prosperity” are all population-related, each of which requires the accumulation of more imports and debt, and a deteriorating current account balance, rather than genuine sustainable growth: Anyone disputing these facts only needs to look at the below chart showing the stalling of export growth amid the sharply deteriorating trade balance: Which has driven a gigantic trade deficit: Yesterday, The ABS released its Jobs in Australia, 2011-12 to 2016-17 survey, which perfectly illustrated the false economy Victoria is running. According to the ABS, median in Victoria is badly lagging the national average:

The median income per job (footnote 4) in Greater Melbourne region was higher than in the Rest of Victoria ($43,800 and $36,700 respectively) in 2016-17. The median income per job grew by 11.7% in Greater Melbourne and 13.9% in the Rest of Victoria since 2011-12. Nationally, the median income per job was $43,200 in 2016-17, slightly higher than the Victoria median of $42,100.

Diving into the data reveals more bad news for Victorians, with Victoria having the second lowest median income on the mainland – only just beating out lowly Adelaide: From highest to lowest, median incomes are as follows across Australia’s jurisdictions:

  1. ACT: $54,774
  2. NT: $47,367
  3. WA: $45,973
  4. NSW: $43,795
  5. QLD: $42,692
  6. VIC: $42,134
  7. SA: $41,400
  8. TAS: $37,219

The story is similar at the capital city level, with Melbourne also having the second lowest median incomes on the mainland, only beating lowly Adelaide: Again, from highest to lowest here are the median incomes across the capitals:

  1. Canberra: $54,774
  2. Darwin: $51,007
  3. Perth: $46,929
  4. Sydney: $46,464
  5. Brisbane: $45,164
  6. Melbourne: $43,791
  7. Adelaide: $42,981
  8. Hobart: $39,446

The annual state accounts from the ABS paint an even worse picture, with Victoria’s household income growth badly lagging behind the other jurisdictions: And Victoria having the lowest gross household disposable income in the nation, even lagging behind Tasmania: Victoria’s population ponzi economy is clearly failing to lift living standards for the incumbent population. In addition to crushing incomes, Melbourne’s infrastructure deficit, along with congestion, housing and overall liveability is worsening each year as more and more people flood into the city and push against bottlenecks amid woeful planning.

Unconventional Economist
Latest posts by Unconventional Economist (see all)


  1. So NT & ACT being Govt towns have highest income, no surprises there. Seems odd SA/Adelaide isn’t higher. Adelaide is a one company town & the company is Government. So I’m surprised the income isn’t higher, although possible as the Real Estate is less than Eastern seaboard. NT surely can’t keep holding up. It is totally stuffed without Fed Govt funding injections. Total basket case. ACT I guess is Head Office, so all OK. Melbourne is a big property play so how will that end, seems unbelievable the development in apartments, but maybe thats not a big deal?

  2. One of the few lobby groups that might begin to have any clout to challenge the population racket is States and Territories. But they are its biggest supporters, even Andrew Barr in the ACT.

    Look what happened when Berejiklian ‘appeared’ to break ranks. Shut down real fast, and her Shergold (why is it always Shergold?) review vanished in a puff. Oh for a non-corrupt Sydney media, to delve deeper.

  3. I’m sure I’ve read on these pages to the effect that Treasury drafts the budget, then makes up the shortfall in GDP with immigration Can someone link me to something that makes the argument in more formal language? thanks.

  4. “Victoria’s population ponzi economy is clearly failing to lift living standards for the incumbent population ..”

    The worst of it is, it’s driving a heap of Victorians to the great state of QLD! We’re already over-run by various other intruders, we don’t need any more!

  5. It’s always a bit shocking when you look at those wage charts and HH disposible income and then think these people have bought 800K+ houses.