Shadow RBA sets course for doom

Man, what a pack of muppets! The Shadow RBA:

Forecast for 2019 Suggests Cash Rate Should Remain On Hold

Australia’s economy has softened, with the growth rate having dropped to 0.3 percent for the September quarter (2.8% annual growth rate) and CPI inflation edging down to 1.8% in the December quarter, below the Reserve Bank of Australia’s official target band of 2-3%. The official unemployment rate remained at 5%. The RBA Shadow Board continues to favour holding the cash rate constant but the uncertainty surrounding its policy recommendation reflects the slight weakening of economic data. More specifically, the Board attaches a 56% probability that holding interest rates steady at 1.5% is the appropriate setting, while the confidence in a required rate hike equals 41% and in a required rate cut equals 3%.

According to the ABS, the seasonally adjusted unemployment rate in Australia remains low, at 5%; the labour force participation rate remains at 65.6%. No new data on nominal wage growth is available since the September quarter figure of 2.3% (annualised). The lower CPI inflation rate may well be matched by lower nominal wage growth (to be announced on 20 February) as there is little indication that the relatively low unemployment rate, which increasingly masks underemployment due to growing part time employment, is exerting upward pressure on wages.

The Aussie dollar (relative to the US dollar), after piercing the psychologically important floor of 70 US¢, has bounced back to around 73 US¢. Yields on Australian 10-year government bonds have fallen considerably, to 2.2%. The new year has seen the Australian share market make steady gains, from a recent low of 5,400 in the S&P/ASX 200 stock index, to 5,900.

There are increasing signs that the global economy may weaken in 2019, even if many countries’ stock markets experienced the usual January rally. In the US, the fiscal boost from Trump’s tax cuts will likely fade, while parts of Europe are flirting with, or already in, recession, i.e. Italy. China’s economy also appears to be slowing, albeit only slightly. Other emerging markets are also stuttering, due to factors ranging from political instability (e.g. Latin America) to unsustainable debt (Asia). Heightened trade tensions between the US and China and security concerns add to the overall uncertainty about the global economic climate.

Consumer confidence has fallen; the Westpac Melbourne Institute Consumer Sentiment Index dipped below 100 this month, whereas retail sales remain unchanged. Business confidence, according to the NAB business confidence index, is the lowest it has been in three years. On the other hand, the manufacturing PMI has increased in January, while the services PMI dropped slightly. Capacity utilisation increased to above 82%.

The real estate sector is noticeably weakening. Building permits are down 9.1% in November, the most recent figure. All other housing indicators, including the construction PMI, construction output, and the housing index, are down. A continuation of this decline will likely affect Australian households’ consumption and investment behaviour and therefore will be monitored closely by the RBA. That said, house prices, despite the recent retreats, are still much higher than they were three years ago, and a measured correction should be welcomed.

The distribution of the Shadow Board’s policy preferences continues to favour holding the interest rate constant. The Shadow Board is 56% confident that keeping interest rates on hold is the appropriate policy, up 3 percentage points from the previous month. It attaches a 3% probability that a rate cut is appropriate (0% in December) and a 41% probability (47% in December) that a rate rise, to 1.75% or higher, is appropriate.

The probabilities at longer horizons are as follows: 6 months out, the estimated probability that the cash rate should remain at 1.50% equals 29%, three percentage points up from the previous round. The estimated need for an interest rate decrease has increased from 6% to 11%, while the probability attached to a required increase has fallen from 68% to 60%. The numbers for the recommendations a year out paint a similar picture. The Shadow Board members’ confidence that the cash rate should be held steady remains unchanged at 16%, while the confidence in a required cash rate decrease equals 11% (7% in December), and in a required cash rate increase 73% (78% in December). The width of the probability distributions over the 6 month and 12 month horizons remains unchanged, extending from 0.75 to 3.5…

Screeching needle off the vinyl…We interrupt this broadcast of straight line trend forecasting to observe that:

  • house prices in Australia’s two largest cities are in outright crashes;
  • building approvals are in an outright crash coast to coast;
  • infrastruture investment has topped out;
  • credit is swiftly falling towards zero;
  • the NAB business survey is in an outright crash signalling the same for investment ahead;
  • car sales are in an outright crash;
  • leading indicators for retail are in an outright crash;
  • leading employment indexes have rolled over sharply;
  • monthly core inflation is at 1.4 per cent and crashing;
  • bank share prices are down 40 per cent as they deliver unprecedented mortgage rate hikes into crashing house prices thanks to rising funding costs;
  • a federal election economic stall is imminent, and
  • the RBA has not hiked rates at all in the cycle to deliver the above, which looks an awful lot like a bursting housing bubble mushrooming into a deleveraging singularity at the very heart of Australia’s thirty year boom.

But you ruler-wielding phonies just hang onto your pride while it all falls apart why don’t you. I would love to see the Shadow hike rates into a crashing economy just to wipe it out once and for all but for obvious reasons that would be stupid.

Let’s not forget that the Shadow RBA is the same august body that developed the institutional version of a personality disorder by refusing to ever mention the words “macroprudential” over the last few years. Now that invisible regulatory force had to pull down the entire economy and it still can’t be said.

This is fantastically inept.


  1. How will rate cuts help anything at this stage? A lower $AUD may help exports, but it will just stop house prices falling as quickly, but it won’t stop them falling. Then what happens when that sugar hit stops?

    • Stop asking questions. We just need to lower teh rates to fix thing ok? These good bloggers told me so. Anyone who doesn’t get it is soooo stoopid.

    • TailorTrashMEMBER

      Yes Gavin I am not an economist but I too don’t understand this . What will it do ?…offer a smidgen of mortgage relief to people so far in debt they can’t see sunlight .
      Get businesses to suddenly rush out and invest in new ventures that create “real “ employment …….yes drop the dolllar …and help exports ….but what does Straya really export apart from dirt, coal our children’s homes and the quality of their education….and how much more elasticity is in them. A lot of folks like me who live off retirement savings will also stop spending as intrest on those savings dry up
      I’m a simple chap so I’d like a simple explanation of how dropping the intrest rates to say zero at this late stage can refloat the sinking good ship Straya .
      …and that’s a genuine question .

    • It’s not about what “ought” to be done – it’s about the RBA doing SOMETHING…which is dropping rates,as that’s basically all it can do…

      People need to stop seeing H&H’s calls as what he steadfastly thinks ought to be done, and more what the RBA “should” do from its own point of view, given its mandate – and he’s correct, IMO.

      The problem is the RBA’s paradigm.

      • Burb
        HnH has NEVER entered into the policy debate on what should be done. He has screamed MP while also ALWAYS advocating ever lower rates to ‘fix thing” He has always argued for the consumption economy – he just didn’t want it in houses. In fact houses are perhaps the least damaging aspect of a consumption economy. MP around housing doesn’t alter the balance of the economy. It doen’t change the funnel – it just changes the filters. In the end we end up going down the same tube.
        Instead of eing a place of worthy policy debate, MB has ended up in a petty schoolboy name-calling mentality.

    • Exports?!! WTF do we still export? Most of that is already negotiated years ahead… we ain’t exporting sh*t

  2. OK I understand that they might provide reasons to adopt the BS policy of dropping rates to try to rescue a BS economy but..;.
    So in that list of “óbservations” please nominate a single item that would qualify as a REAL reason to drop rates on a POLICY basis – if our aim is a productive economy.

  3. SupernovaMEMBER
    Central bankers desperately looking for an excuse (via fake statistical economic modelling) to cover their disastrous QE & NIRP experiment…..that they actually increase inequality not reduce it. QE and NIRP used to save globalists namely themselves and fellow bureaucrats, the bankers and their corporate clients, not reduce inequality but increase it. QE & NIRP will only increase populism and clearly demonstrates a reduction in middle class living standards as Europe is now clearly demonstrating. I therefore agree with the shadow board that interest rates remain on hold as lowering them would be a move toward towards NIRP and QE….keep rates on hold!