Coal still doomed

The new look US Department of Energy released a big report last week on the power industry. As a reminder this is the report commissioned by the new Secretary of Energy, Rick Perry, who seemed as if he had already written the conclusion that “coal was king” and was just looking for someone to come up with something vaguely plausible to support his view when he wrote the terms:

 “regulatory burdens introduced by previous administrations that were designed to decrease coal-fired power generation. Such policies have destroyed jobs and economic growth, and the threatened to undercut the performance of the grid well into the future”

The good news for the coal lobby is that a report designed to “to exercise foresight to help ensure a system that is reliable, resilient, and affordable long into the future” contains the phrase “climate change” zero times.

The bad news for the coal lobby is that the report really doesn’t support the “regulation and renewables have ruined us” line that the coal lobby likes to trot out.

The leaked version of the report (before it had been sent to Perry for grooming) was pretty direct about: (a) coal being a victim of low gas prices, (b) renewable subsidies being relatively marginal in closing down coal plants and (c) retirement of coal plants hadn’t affected reliability and that the power mix was more diverse than ever.

The official version of the report was a lot softer on (c) in particular, and so some of Perry’s overall conclusions designed to help the coal industry are contradicted by the detail of the report. Not that I think that the contradictions will bother Perry or Trump overly, but it does show that whatever short term benefit the coal industry may get from Trump, it will likely be quickly reversed once reality matters.

We have looked at grid power vs solar and batteries a few times recently (see here and here in particular), and there was nothing ground-breakingly new in this latest report to suggest issues with any of our analysis.

I have included a bunch of the more interesting charts from the report below, noting that the comments in the yellow boxes and texta marks are mine:

Age of US thermal electricity plants Age of US gas fired electricity plants Improving efficiency of gas plants US GDP no longer reliant on electricity power efficiency gains in the US Electricity forecasts have been over-optimistic    

Increasing diversity of electricity sources in the US

Damien Klassen is Chief Investment Officer at the Macrobusiness Fund, which is powered by Nucleus Wealth.

The information on this blog contains general information and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Damien Klassen is an authorised representative of Nucleus Wealth Management, a Corporate Authorised Representative of Integrity Private Wealth Pty Ltd, AFSL 436298.

Follow me
Latest posts by Damien Klassen (see all)


  1. Aluminium Air battery;:Notably, in 2016, an Al–air battery weighing 100 kg was fabricated and shown to be capable of extendingthe range of an electric vehicle to over 3000 km.
    Many research groups have been dedicated to enhancing the capacity and lifetime of Al–air battery systems however there are still many hurdles to overcome.
    Just like the 8 track stereo, or the film camera??

    • 3000km? Are you sure about that? That would involve an incredible energy density exceeding IC fuels. It sounds good, but sometimes a decimal place gets misplaced.

      • Google Aluminium Air batteries, you’ll get the info and the links
        If there are any achieving bright lights out there I suggest you learn how air cathodes work and know inside out the oxidation reactions which occur there. you’ll make more money than that immigrant Highrise harry.
        (surely that will get em off the street)

      • they are primary cells, mechanical recharge every 3000km, each regular service
        Not intended to be rechargeable.

      • Those commie engineers have perfected the art of reverse engineering and/or outright IP theft. R&D takes effort and money.

      • Ya remember the RR nene engine, sold to russia (a bunch of useless commie farmers) cos the labor govt of the UK was broke
        Well it was reverse engineered, better and came back to bite us in the form of the MIG 15 in the Korean war
        shot down a heap of our men. still the most produced fighter in the world today.
        Rememebr that????
        that was the start of the downfall of the UK
        the USA never trusted the uk from then on and still doesnt today, and nor do we -me WW