Sell side blows on China rate cuts

Advertisement

From Danske Bank:

While it was clear that there was a slight easing bias in monetary policy in China, the interest rate cut was nonetheless a bit of a surprise. It suggests that China now has a more substantial easing bias in monetary policy and the government’s attempt to contain credit growth will be loosened somewhat in coming months. Hence, supporting growth now appears to be a higher priority.

The implication of today’s interest rate cut is that the Chinese growth manufacturing PMIs and growth have probably bottomed out and should start to improve in Q1 when investment demand and particularly the property market will start to rebound. The interest rate cut is particularly important for the property market where the 40bp cut in the benchmark lending rate is still important for mortgage interest rates. The growth outlook is definitely more positive for H1 15. However, we do not expect to see a sharp rebound in growth next year as the government will still be focused on managing financial risk and securing sustainable credit growth. Hence, the PBoC will continue to ease only cautiously and we do not expect it to cut rates further. In addition, China remains in a structural slowdown, which will continue to weigh on growth further ahead.

The interest rate cut is extremely positive for risk sentiment and risky assets in general in financial markets and it is particularly positive for emerging markets and commodities.

Hence, it should help commodity and Emerging Market currencies like the Norwegian krone, the Australian dollar, Canada dollar, Brazilian real, Mexican peso and the South African rand.

Base metal prices and oil prices have reacted instantly to the news with Brent up 50 cent.

An integral part of the recent weakness in commodity markets has been the weakness in the Chinese economy – the rate cut should support Chinese growth and thereby support a recovery in commodity prices. The oil market in particular has been longing for support from the demand side since the sharp decline in prices started in early September. The rate cut will, therefore, be an important factor in supporting the expected recovery in oil prices. Therefore, the news supports our call for a higher oil prices next year – in 2015 we forecast Brent at USD94/bbl.

Balls. China’s October data stank and it was obvious more stimulus would be necessary. That is, to head off a faster fall. From ANZ:

We believe today’s rate cut clearly signals that China’s central bank has changed its monetary policy stance to a more ‘accommodative’ one. In fact, the conditions for further policy easing are ripe: First, China has entered into a rapid dis-inflation process as CPI inflation dropped to below 2% and PPI inflation has remained negative for more than two years. Second, the economy continues to slow down with Q3 GDP growth declining to the slowest pace since the global financial crisis, and China could run the risk of missing the growth target of 7.5% this year if without further policy easing. In the meantime, the costs of funding facing Chinese corporates remained elevated, as the weighted average lending rates even picked up slightly around 7% in Q3 compared with that of Q2, despite many newly invented but ineffective policy tools have been experimented so far this year.

Meanwhile, China’s State Council also released 10 measures this week to lower firms’ funding costs, and asked the banking regulator to relax the requirement of loan-to-deposit ratio for the commercial banks. Against this backdrop, today’s rate cut suggests that the overall policy orientation has shifted to be more supportive.

More supportive to prevent a collapse, yes, not to reverse the structural adjustment. Once the excitement passes, nothing has changed for risk assets or commodities.

Advertisement
About the author
David Llewellyn-Smith is Chief Strategist at the MB Fund and MB Super. David is the founding publisher and editor of MacroBusiness and was the founding publisher and global economy editor of The Diplomat, the Asia Pacific’s leading geo-politics and economics portal. He is also a former gold trader and economic commentator at The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, the ABC and Business Spectator. He is the co-author of The Great Crash of 2008 with Ross Garnaut and was the editor of the second Garnaut Climate Change Review.