Chinese property bailouts proliferate

Advertisement
bigstock-bailout-or-bankruptcy-economic-54368810

Chinese authorities attempts to balance their reform and growth agendas have resulted in another bailout of a looming bond default. From Reuters:

A troubled Chinese construction company avoided a landmark bond default at the last minute on Wednesday, raising enough funds to pay off both principal and interest on a 400 million yuan ($64.51 million) bond, people directly involved in the matter told Reuters.

The people said there was aggressive fundraising by Huatong Road & Bridge Group Co Ltd, as well as collection of its accounts payable by a local government in Shanxi province, where the firm is based.

The moves let Huatong steer away from what would have been the first public default in China’s massive interbank bond market – where 94 percent of all Chinese bonds are issued.

…Analysts said many receivables involved other local government bodies that had hired Huatong to build real estate projects, then delayed payment due to their own financial difficulties.

The analysts also said avoidance of a default is unlikely to reassure China’s fixed income markets, which have seen steadily rising rates for short-term debt as demands from cash-strapped companies for money continue.

“No market can sustain a status quo of no-defaults,” a trader at an Asian bank in Shanghai said. “Chinese authorities will find one day that they cannot support all money-losing companies.”

Another can firmly kicked. And there’s good fortune for Chinese specufestors too. Via Investing in Chinese Stocks:

Advertisement

In China, home buyers sometimes demand the right to return a home when a developer has violated the terms of a contract. Many home buyers also demand this if there’s nothing wrong, but simply want out of an investment that it plummeting in value.

In Yulin city in Shaanxi province, 10 developers are now facing buyers who want to return their homes. The slowdown in the coal industry has hurt the local economy and many home buyers face tighter financial conditions. Developers are already in trouble due to the weak economy and a wave of buyers demanding their money back is more bad news.

In one case, 300 buyers claim a developer used illegal sales tactics. The developer required a ¥200,000 down payment, but later required a ¥300,000 transfer payment. Buyers felt they had to make the second payment to protect their non-refundable deposit. The developer claims that a third party investor selling the properties asked for that payment, not itself.

In another case, hundreds of buyers have returned homes due to the developer’s failure to deliver on time. The developer is now extremely short on cash. Another has buyers demanding a return of their money because the developer sold them apartments with one bedroom, one kitchen, one bathroom and one living room, but left off the living room when it was built.

The government is helping buyers get their money back, but it also tells them to be on guard for fraud.

Opinion is mixed on the issue. One middle aged man said he can understand why people want to get their money back now that the value of homes is tumbling. A retired teacher said people need to bear the cost of decisions, whether the result is positive or negative. A construction firm owner said when prices were rising, everyone was taking out loans and buying, now that prices are falling, integrity goes out the window and people are looking for any way out. A senior media person said if morality is abandoned when home prices fall, the housing crisis will be followed by an even larger financial crisis.

Elsewhere, developers in Hohhot are under pressure too, cutting prices in the range of 10% to 15%. One engineering firm said many developers are paying their bills one to two months late, and in one case 2 years late. Debts can only be paid by taking possession of the property or seizing the owners luxury cars, similar to how debts are being settled in Ordos.

This may be the most extreme case of a buyer “returning their home.” Some Beijing residents who won the affordable housing lottery (which had odds of 4000 to 1) have given up their right to buy. Affordable housing sells for 20% to 30% below surrounding properties, but thanks to falling prices, buyers are willing to forego this opportunity.

Does anyone, anywhere pay a price for mis-allocating their capital these days?

About the author
David Llewellyn-Smith is Chief Strategist at the MB Fund and MB Super. David is the founding publisher and editor of MacroBusiness and was the founding publisher and global economy editor of The Diplomat, the Asia Pacific’s leading geo-politics and economics portal. He is also a former gold trader and economic commentator at The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, the ABC and Business Spectator. He is the co-author of The Great Crash of 2008 with Ross Garnaut and was the editor of the second Garnaut Climate Change Review.