Iceland’s lessons on how to fix a bank crisis

I’m slowly working my way through the material that’s coming out of World Economic Forum in Davos. I tend not to take too much attention of what is said at this particular conference as, in my opinion, it tends to be full of self-serving tripe in the most part.

I did, however, notice a small interview with Icelandic President, Olafur Ragnar Grimsson, which was quite interesting.

There are two  reasons why this is such an interesting interview.

Firstly, Mr Grimsson raises some very good points about the effect a large financial services industry on the rest of the economy. He also asks the important question as to why exactly a private bank should be treated differently from any other private enterprise even if has some strategic importance and why exactly national citizens should suffer due to poor business practices. In that regard, Iceland, much like Sweden, has become a model of what should be done after a banking crisis. In short, the aim of the game is to save the banks, but not the bankers.

There is, however, one small problem with Mr Grimsson’s points. He appears to be doing some fairly large historical revisionism in the account of what actually happened. The Icelandic government was not ‘wise’ in it’s implementation of a non-orthodox approach at all. It actually attempted to keep some of the banking system alive, including giving them money along with ‘un-lawful’ loans and part of the IMF program that came later was used save a number of building societies.

It is correct to state that Iceland didn’t bail out its three large banks that collapsed in October 2008, but this was simply because at 900% of GDP it was absolutely impossible. The Government did initially attempt to save Glitnir, but it became apparent very quickly that the central bank did not have the foreign reserves available to keep the banking system alive.

In the end Iceland did become a lesson for the rest of the world in how to best manage the crisis, but the initial response certainly wasn’t planned and certainly wasn’t due to the wisdom of the government. If you are interested in reading some future information I recommend you start here and here.

17 Responses to “ “Iceland’s lessons on how to fix a bank crisis”

  1. AB says:

    Another good link here – http://studiotendra.com/2012/12/29/what-is-actually-going-on-in-iceland/

    “Since people continue to spread the factually dubious statement that Iceland “told creditors & IMF to go jump, nationalised banks, arrested the fraudsters, gave debt relief and is now growing very strongly, thanks” I find I have to write this here thing.”

  2. Pfh007 says:

    Yes – If anything the politicians were desperate to please their mates in Europe.

    Mr recollection is that it took some vetoes by the President and a couple of referenda before the pollies got ‘wise’

    Planet Money ran a number of good podcasts on the subject.

    http://www.npr.org/templates/archives/archive.php?thingId=136585033

  3. SMc says:

    When you see a deal that looks too good to be true then you can bet your house it is… the rates that Icesave were offering were just unbelievable.. all from a country that has nothing but puffins, dried fish and some geothermal energy to offer where could the money be coming from??

    maybe as there are about 30% of the population who believe in Elves.. perhaps they were thinking that Lord Elron would guarantee such fantastic returns..

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icelandic_Elf_School

    they even have a school for those poor souls.

    • DaveC says:

      I counsel against smugness. Australia has plenty of weird beliefs.

      Judging from recent posting on a thread about the ‘housing shortage’, it seems clear that a lot of folks round here are still in thrall to the Efficient Markets Hypothesis.

  4. raveswei says:

    “It is correct to state that Iceland didn’t bail out its three large banks that collapsed in October 2008, but this was simply because at 900% of GDP it was absolutely impossible.”

    “too big to be saved”?

  5. Hewell says:

    The Ironborn, who believe in the Drowned God, would drown a man and then bring him back to life. The near death experience would mark him one of the holy Drowned Men.

    “What’s dead may never die.”

    Maybe we aught to do the same to our banks. Make them, as well as the nation, stronger.

    Not all men are successfully revived though.

  6. [...] for solar energy. The wind industry has a record year.Around The World: $217 in the BankIceland teaches a few lessons on how to solve a banking crisis. France’s labor minister says the country is “totally [...]

  7. [...] teaches a few lessons on how to solve a banking crisis. France’s labor minister says the country is “totally [...]

  8. [...] teaches a few lessons on how to solve a banking crisis. France’s labor minister says the country is “totally [...]

  9. [...] teaches a few lessons on how to solve a banking crisis. France’s labor minister says the country is “totally [...]

  10. [...] teaches a few lessons on how to solve a banking crisis. France’s labor minister says the country is “totally [...]

  11. [...] Iceland teaches a few lessons on how to solve a banking crisis. France’s labor minister says the country is “totally bankrupt.” Zimbabwe has $217 left in the bank. South Korea leads the world in per capita plastic surgery. Charles and Camilla take a ride on the tube. Retail sales in Germany decline. Vladimir Putin hires Boyz II Men to promote Russian fertility. Canada’s G.D.P.increases. David Beckham pledges his salary to charity. [...]

  12. [...] teaches a few lessons on how to solve a banking crisis. France’s labor minister says the country is “totally [...]

  13. [...] By Delusional Economics, who is determined to cleanse the daily flow of vested interests propaganda to produce a balanced counterpoint. Cross posted from MacroBusiness. [...]